(A response to Chris Trotter’s “Ruins of the White House’s East Wing symbolise the passing of an old order and the arrival of a new one“)
Chris, this is some world-class melodrama. We’re talking about replacing a set of bland 1940s office spaces with a privately funded ballroom, not detonating the Constitution. Presidents have been knocking holes in the White House since before New Zealand was even a country. Truman didn’t just move a wall — he gutted the entire residence because it was falling apart. Teddy Roosevelt built the West Wing. FDR moved the Oval Office. Nixon filled in a swimming pool and turned it into the press briefing room because, apparently, bowling was more important. Obama turned the tennis court into a basketball court. And the Republic carried on.
But Trump renovates some staff offices and suddenly it’s the end of American democracy? That’s not analysis — that’s a soap opera script. There are genuine reasons to criticize Trump. A construction project on federal property isn’t one of them. Yet here we are, pretending a backhoe is a symbol of tyranny and a ballroom is Versailles 2.0. If the presence of event space is the trigger for authoritarianism, then every Marriott in America is an emerging monarchy.
You also might want to check the facts: this isn’t the East Wing being “reduced to rubble” by a rogue emperor; it’s a planned, routine renovation that’s happened countless times before, paid for by private donors, and intended to eliminate the need for those tacky lawn tents every administration has used when more than 200 people show up. The horror! Guests seated somewhere that isn’t a plastic party enclosure. Surely Madison and Hamilton weep.
If changing a workspace is “the passing of the old order,” then moving the Oval Office in 1934 was the end of civilization. Spoiler: it wasn’t. The White House is a living building, updated constantly to meet the needs of the presidency. Treating a construction photo like a prophecy of dictatorship doesn’t make you insightful — it makes you the guy yelling “fire” because someone lit a scented candle.
Pull yourself together, man. When democracy falls, it won’t be because a ballroom was added. It’ll be because people were too busy clutching their pearls over routine renovation to focus on anything that actually matters.
Featured image: “White House lawn” by Daniel Schwen, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0. Image cropped/resized for display.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.